METHOD
Business Motivation Model
Origins and purpose of the model
The Business Motivation Model (BMM) was originally conceived by the Object Management Group. (For the original details, see BMM at OMG). The model is useful for organising strategic thought and content in a consistent manner, over time, and across various disciplines/capabilities within a business or organisation. We have prepared a simplified explanation of the original concept.
In this method resource, we guide the creation of a simplified version of the BMM for the layperson and small/medium businesses to create and use.
Method
A. Creating a Business Motivation Model
- Decide on a time period for your BMM. We recommend a one to two year period with the expectation that you will review this every three or six months to see if the contents need to be adapted.
- Start your strategic planning with understanding what value the business should create in the chosen time period. Explore the vocabulary of Business Value elements (available in our card deck). The value elements become the stimuli for choosing strategiesto create such value, and goalsthat measure the value created or generated. (Every goal should have a direct correlation to one or more elements of value.) A good way explore desired value is to compose a desired-future Business Value Exchange Ledger.
- Decide whether you want to capture your thoughts initially in the tabular format in a digital document (like MS Word or MS Excel) or go more free form with Sticky Notes and a large blank surface (whiteboard or butcher paper).
- Use your thinking from the Value Exchange Ledger™ to initially populate the lower rows of the model: Strategies–Tacticsand Goals–Objectives.
Tip: Keep it really simple the first time you do this, and merge the Strategies-Tactics and Goals-Objectives — the additional granularity might not serve you well at this stage. Thus:
- Goals = the Measure of Value you seek to create or generate
- Strategies = the Activities you intend to do to create or generate that measure of value
- Extend your thinking and be creative about other potential Goals and Strategies that may not have been revealed in the two value-based methods. It’s entirely up to you to decide the range, scope and number of items you want to put in the model.
- When you feel you have a core set of Strategies, then compose a summary statement about these, which is your Mission. When you have a core set of Goals, then compose a summary statement about these, which is your Vision.
Note 1: The Mission and Vision in the BMM is ONLY an overarching statement that fits with the time period (i.e. 1-2 years) of your BMM. This Mission and Vision is for an internal audience only. This Mission and Vision is likely to be different and separate from your overarching statement of what the business/organisation exists for — and those statements are generally composed with an external audience in mind with a lot of word-smithing involved. It’s not worth investing a lot of time nor effort in word-smithing the Mission and Vision for your BMM. (NB: If you are maintaining a fuller Business Architecture for your organisation/business — that is a range of views/diagrams/models — then put your external facing Mission and Vision in a separate section to the BMM.
Note 2: This order of populating the model is based on the fact that many people don’t naturally think in abstractions or strategically. Rather than taking an idealistic top-down approach to populate Mission and Vision first, this is done last. Most people when doing future planning have a list of actions (Means) in mind before they have a list of things they want to achieve (Ends).
- A key feature of the Motivation Model concept is coherency. So as you populate the final version of your BMM model, take regular moments to check the logic and coherence of the contents. See the Example below of a populated model.
- A reference numbering system can be helpful.
- Give each Strategy a whole number, e.g. 1.0; 2.0
- Give each Tactic a part number showing which strategy it relates to, e.g. 2.1; 2.2
- Match the Goals to the Strategy so they have the same reference number. Strategy 1.0 – Goal 1.0
- Use these questions as prompters:
- Does each Strategy have a Goal that is meaningful?
- Does each Tactic belong to a Strategy?
- Does each Tactic have an Objective that is measurable? (And you get to define what makes something measurable — be creative, it’s your BMM.)
- Does the Mission reflect a summary of all Strategies?
- Does the Vision reflect a summary of all the Goals?
- Is there Value you seek to create or generate that doesn’t yet have a Strategy/Goal combo?
- Use the Tip below (Disambiguiating the concepts) to check the language you have used to ensure it is in fact a Strategy or Tactic and not a Goal or Objective.
- A reference numbering system can be helpful.
- Set yourself a diary appointment for the future when you can review and update the model contents. Every quarter (3 months) or half year is a good time period.
- Put a copy of the completed BMM somewhere you can easily reference it.
Tips for creating a BMM
1. Disambiguating the concepts
It is common to confuse a statement of Strategy (a Means) as an End (a Goal) simply from the choice of syntax. This happens when a strategy is written as the thing to be achieved (i.e. What) rather than the means by which it will be achieved (e.g. How).
To avoid this problem and compose statements that have better implicit meaning, follow this tip: Write Ends statements in past (or present) tense as a noun phrase – as if the End has been achieved.
BAD
“Improve customer satisfaction across all products and services within two years.” [Verb Phrase]
GOOD
“Improved Customer Satisfaction across all products and services within two years” [Noun Phrase in past tense]
A companion tip: Write a Strategy (Means) statement in present tense as a verb phrase. Test the sense-making of what you wrote by saying ‘We will <Strategy> to achieve <Goal>.
“Redevelop products and services based on customer feedback.” [Verb Phrase in present tense]
TEST
We will Redevelop products and services based on customer feedback to achieve Improved Customer Satisfaction across all products and services within two years.
2. Connecting to a Business Model Canvas
If you have created a Business Model Canvas (BMC) to show a To-Be/Future perspective of what your business is to become, then consider this an input to your strategic planning. Ask: What strategic and tactical action is needed to make your business model a reality?
- Key Activities & Key Resources: Are there new capabilities and functions to create; existing capabilities and functions to grow; existing capabilities and functions to retire or close? Are ther
- Key Partners: Are there new partners to acquire; existing partners to strengthen; existing partners to retire?
- Revenue Streams: Are their new products and services to development; existing products and services to improve; existing products and services to retire?
- … and explore the other areas of the BMC with such questions.
3. Connecting to Business Value Flow Mapping Method
One way to refine your thinking of the important value elements to include in your BMM is the Business Value Flow Mapping method. It may well be that your BMM needs a mix of Instrumental and Terminal value elements.
B. Using your Business Motivation Model
- Retrieve your completed BMM from its stored location.
- When making plans for the coming weeks or month, use the BMM as your guide to what the business should be focusing on.
- You may need to do further planning to decompose a Strategy (or even a Tactic) into Tasks that can be done. Consider a tool like a Kanban Board for storing and focusing your attention on Task levels of work. Your BMM is for strategic-level content, and would not normally go into a work management system or tool — except maybe to reference the Strategy or Goal that the Tasks are contributing to. (And that’s why the number system is very handy!)
- As the business implements the plans, be sure to take note of any quantifiable factors that can help evaluate progress to achieving the stated Goals.
- You can put text or graphical elements in/on your model to show the status or progress. This might be as simple as words “DONE” or “DOING” or symbols/emojis that have similar meaning. It’s good to track your progress against your intentions.
- At the end of the time-period given to your BMM, do a holistic evaluation of what was done and achieved. Consider what lessons learned you might carry forward to the creation of the next BMM!
Example of a BMM for a small business
Here is an example of a Business Motivation Model for a small knowledge-work business. The strategic value to be created/acquired notated as [Value element] next to Goals.
This derivative work by RHX Group — product owner of value(x) — is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. We acknowledge and respect the original work and property of the Object Management Group.
